On June 20, 2024, Yellowstone teased the return of its fifth season with a video promoting the show’s November 10 release. While the teaser created excitement, many fans expressed disappointment over Kevin Costner’s absence, with some questioning the show’s value without him. Comments ranged from “No Costner, no show” to “It’s not the same without Kevin.”

Costner later confirmed in an Instagram video that he would not be returning, citing his commitment to his new project, Horizon. He explained that after a long period of reflection, he realized continuing with Yellowstone wasn’t realistic anymore, though he expressed his love for the series.

Since its debut, Costner’s portrayal of John Dutton, patriarch of the Dutton family, has been beloved. Luke Grimes, who plays his on-screen son, Kayce, acknowledged the show’s shift without Costner, noting that the family’s story was always headed in this direction.