On January 9, 2025, the National Cathedral in Washington, D.C., hosted a memorial for former President Jimmy Carter, who had reached 100 years old and became the longest-living U.S. president. The service, however, stirred controversy when close friends Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood performed John Lennon’s anthem “Imagine,” with some criticizing its lyrics, especially “Imagine there’s no heaven… Above us only sky,” as inappropriate for a Christian funeral.

While some viewers expressed displeasure, questioning how the song aligned with Carter’s faith, others defended it as a heartfelt tribute. Brooks and Yearwood had a long-standing friendship with Carter, working together on Habitat for Humanity projects. For them, “Imagine” represented Carter’s vision for peace and unity, a belief Carter himself had often spoken about, calling the song a “national anthem” in places like Cuba.

WATCH: Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood perform “Imagine” at the funeral of former President Jimmy Carter in Washington pic.twitter.com/3NMvGLWjoE

— PBS News (@NewsHour) January 9, 2025

Brooks and Yearwood’s performance, despite the backlash, reflected their deep respect for Carter’s legacy of service and dedication to a better world. The tribute, while divisive, underscored Carter’s lasting impact and the enduring admiration he inspired in those closest to him.